Posts  / #POST-001637
REDDIT

Moderate chance I'll need to dip into roth principal when I buy a home. With that in mind, should I be investing in bonds, or should I still playing the long term game with stocks?

F
Feb 14, 2025 · 05:20

My empoyer allows the mega backdoor roth strategy, where after tax 401k contributions are converted to roth contributions, and then rolled over to a Roth IRA. I can do about $40k worth of this a year. I have not been taking advantage of this because I have been saving for a home down payment.

I'm at point now where I have enough to make a 15-20% downpayment on a home, which is great. But, depending on the home I buy, I may need more cash lying around to fund projects & renovations (which is not something I can easily finance into the loan, home renovation loans have a lot of strings, and can make my offer uncompetitive).

But, because there's a chance I might not need to touch this money - and because you always withdraw roth principal (your contributions) penalty-free, I figure now is a good time to start prioriting roth contributions over after-tax savings. My questions for you is, should I be investing my roth funds into the stock market (i.e. VTI/VXUS), bonds, or short-term cash equivalents (1-3 month T-Bills, SGOV, MMFs, etc)?

Details:

* Income: $275k - a significant portion of this is commission and company stock, however. I might break $300k this year, but if the market performs poorly I might fall back to $260k.
* Liquid Net worth: ~$375k
* $161k in retirement, all in on VTI/VXUS.
* $20k in immediate cash (Treasury MMF)
* $132k in cash-equivalent bonds (1-3 month T-Bills, SGOV)
* $55k in after-tax investments (almost entirely VTI)
* Home Purchase: I'll probably buy something in the $600-850k range, putting $120-135k down, with potentially $15k in closing costs (depending on whether or not the seller will cover it). I may wish to put more down than this, but that would involve selling my stocks. All in all, I could end up paying as little as $120k, or as much as $180k (depending on the cost of the house, and how much mortgage debt I want to take on).

What do you guys think? **I'm not concerned about withdrawing roth contributions because I wouldn't be making them otherwise (*a temporary roth contribution seems better than no roth at all*)**, and I would have the freedom to add back when I withdrew in the future (given the high limit).