Having a look at performance of stocks recommended as "favorite value stock" in a big thread 3 years ago

Here is the September 2023 thread: [https://www.reddit.com/r/ValueInvesting/comments/16jxipd/what\_is\_your\_favorite\_value\_stock\_that\_youll/](https://www.reddit.com/r/ValueInvesting/comments/16jxipd/what_is_your_favorite_value_stock_that_youll/)

S&P 500 is +66.83% since then

Dow Jones is +51.78%

Top recommended stocks in the order of most upvoted:

Alexandria $ARE | -55.36%
MUSA | 75.78%
COKE | 45.66%
AMR | 50.11%
Berkshire | 31.22%
LMT | 19.46%
Unilever | 23.45%
dollar general | 11.88%
Nintendo | 40.23%
Volkswagen | -15.11%
Philips NV | 32.03%
Protector Forsikring | 88.35%
$PBR | 13.52%
TSMC | 152.41%
$FAST | 69.96%
JPM | 130.12%
MSFT | 21.89%
Disney | 17.28%
Alibaba | 35.01%
WBD | -48.29%
BOMN | -24.16%
PAYPAL | -9.87%
WM | 57.41%
Hershey | -18.23%
CROX | 42.15%
Texas pacific land trust | 112.34%
$PFE | -21.50%
Aflac | 38.76%
Verbio | -49.12%
Enphase | -34.65%
Qualcomm | 95.18%
KO | 14.32%
BRK.B | 31.22%
Apple | 39.47%
Nvidia | 364.82%
Tesla | -18.91%
LVMH | -8.43%
Microsoft | 21.89%
Bayer | -52.14%
ASML | 61.54%
Peabody Energy (BTU) | 12.78%

Total return on investment if equal amount was invested in every recommended stock: +34.01%