I’m building a trading dashboard and I need feedback from people who actually trade.
The app shows:
* WAIT / BUY ENTRY / SELL ENTRY
* active trade status
* entry zone
* stop loss
* TP1 / TP2
* invalidation
* confirmation checklist
* signal reason
* trade result tracking
I’m trying to avoid the usual fake signal-app problem where it just shows random BUY/SELL labels that look good after the fact.
The logic I’m trying to build around is:
* closed-candle confirmation only
* no repainting after refresh
* no signal if risk/reward is bad
* no signal if TP is unrealistic
* no signal if the setup is not confirmed
* WAIT instead of forcing trades
* track whether TP or stop hits first
I need brutal feedback on what would make this trustworthy or untrustworthy.
Questions:
1. What would make you immediately distrust a signal dashboard?
2. How would you judge if TP/SL levels are realistic?
3. Should the app show fewer confirmed trades and more WAIT states?
4. What confirmation would you require before a BUY/SELL signal?
5. What should I remove so it does not look like indicator spam?
Not selling anything. I’m trying to figure out if the logic and UX actually make sense before launching.