Posts  / #POST-209911
REDDIT

MSCI & Morningstar quietly tweak ESG metrics amid escalating Gaza crisis

O
May 12, 2025 · 04:17

Two ESG rating giants, MSCI and Morningstar, allegedly altered their methodologies to downplay human rights violations in Gaza and the Occupied Palestinian Territories.

A leak-led investigation shows MSCI recently stopped factoring in these violations - e.g., Caterpillar’s involvement in the demolition of Palestinian villages, which in 2003 had involved the death of US activist Rachel Corrie - into ESG scores, boosting ratings from 3/10 to 10/10 despite no changes in corporate behavior. Motorola also saw its rating improve, despite ongoing involvement in Israeli surveillance systems for settlements illegal under international law.

Morningstar admitted to recently changing its evaluation criteria after pressure from pro-Israel lobby groups like JLens, excluding the region entirely from human rights analysis.

Critics, including Norway’s largest pension fund, argue this undermines investor trust in data integrity of ESGs. Manipulation tied to geopolitical lobbying could distort a €2.8T market and calls into question which ESG investing is genuinely ethical.

Source: [article on Italian newspaper "Il Sole 24 Ore"](https://www.ilsole24ore.com/art/due-societa-che-valutano-indici-sostenibilita-ignorano-abusi-gaza-AHfnhBf) (in Italian)

Post image