When it comes to Trump's tariffs on America's largest trading partners, there was not a lot of good news this week. No one's even pretending to have hope on Canada and Mexico. The EU is signaling they'll be patient, but it's pretty clear by that they mean they're willing to patiently wait for Trump to back down.
And China responded to Trump claiming talks were going well by *denying talks were happening at all*. It's also been reported that China is lifting its own retaliatory tariffs on some semiconductors and some pharmaceuticals, but that seems to be a matter of reducing the pain tariffs cause for China while keeping the pain on the for the US.
When it comes to America's second tier of trading partners—countries like India and Japan—there's more reason for optimism. Talks are at least actually happening. Unfortunately, whether any deals *actually* happen probably depends on how convincingly everyone else involved can lie to Trump and convince him the deals will do what he wants, when clearly no deal will do any such thing.
The problem, here, is that Trump's stated goal is the *total elimination of the US trade deficit.*Not that he regularly uses technical jargon like "trade deficit", but he talks constantly how much money we're "losing" from trade, and when he gives numbers they generally appear to be based on real statistics about the trade deficit.
For example, when Trump announced new tariffs on almost every country in the world on April 2nd, he claimed they were retaliation for other countries' tariffs, "including currency manipulation and trade barriers". But the actual numbers were just our trade deficit with each country in percentile terms. Trump appears to assume any trade deficit is in itself proof of unfair trade practices.
Similarly, he's consistently claimed that under Biden we were "losing" $2 billion a day to other countries. Sometimes the number is $3 billion—while taking questions in the Oval Office on Tuesday the number somehow got up to $5 billion—but $2-3 billion is consistent with the actual goods trade deficit for most of the Biden administration, which tended to be somewhere between $60 billion and $90 billion for any given month.
It's not really clear why you'd *want* to eliminate this trade deficit, since it's largely being driven the US being seen as a great place to invest in, creating enormous international demand for US stocks and bonds, including but by no means limited to US Treasuries. But even if you *did* want to eliminate the trade deficit, it's not clear what a series of deals with other countries to eliminate it would even look like.
That means the deals US trade negotiators are currently attempting to hammer out with their foreign counterparts *will not accomplish Trump's stated goals*. That, in turn, means selling those deals to Trump is going to depend on people bullshitting him into thinking the deals do things they will not and cannot do. Will it work? Maybe. I certainly can't blame people for trying.
But I also can't avoid seeing the parallels with what happened with Canada and Mexico in February and March. Trump threatened them with tariffs on February 1st, then announced a 30 day "pause" after Trudeau and Sheinbaum offered him a bunch of "concessions" that consisted mostly of things they were already doing. For a moment, it looked like catastrophe may have been averted by the power of sheer bullshit. But then, on March 4th, the tariffs went into effect on schedule.
Two days later, I went into my Vanguard account and sold more or less everything, abandoning my longstanding commitment to "VT and chill". So far, I don't regret it.
Note: in the screenshot below "other stocks" is currently 100% IAU, a gold ETF with a slightly lower expense ratio than it's somewhat better-known counterpart GLD.