Posts  / #POST-206623
REDDIT

Liquidity theater

2
Apr 13, 2025 · 02:36

**TL;DR: Passive investors have become the final stop for risk that institutions don’t want to price anymore.**

ETFs are praised for low cost and high liquidity. But they also provide:

• In-kind creation/redemption mechanics that allow **Authorized Participants** (Citadel, JPMorgan, Goldman Sachs, UBS, Deutsche, etc) to offload assets without touching the open market.

*AKA: “We didn’t sell individual Mag 7 stocks, we gave a bundle of them to the ETF Sponsor and sold the SPY shares they paid us with. Selling stocks is unpatriotic.*

The obvious intent of transferring the blocks of common shares of AAPL, NVDA, META, and/or MSFT to the sponsor is to ~~bundle them with house and auto~~ convert them to an asset that targets 401(k) passive liquidity.

• Opacity of underlying flows — Filings provided by these funds are approximately as transparent as the 3% tint on the 4Runner that’s been tailing you for the past 3 blocks.

• A legal structure that allows substitution, as long as the assets meet broad mandates. Ethically spicy, but legally sound and verified by a reputable auditor located in the Cayman Islands.

*If you’re a large institution holding a distressed, stale, or structurally unsellable security, ETFs are the perfect outlet:*

• Deliver it to the ETF sponsor

• Get ETF shares in return

• Exit the ETF shares into retail liquidity

*“No need to sell garbage for a capital gain. Just make it someone else’s index exposure.”* \-Aristotle (unconfirmed, but likely)

**Mutual Fund Conversions: Risk Offloading via Passive Trust**

Mutual funds couldn’t hide:

• They publish NAVs

• They report redemptions

• They sell into real markets

But why unpatriotically sell equity risk into the open market at a bid/ask spread, when you could deposit risk with an ETF Sponsor, create ETF shares, and transfer it to passive 401(k)s with no tax liability like a true patriot (buyer of first resort).

Enter: *SEC Rule 6c-11*.

Have some radioactive *Lehman XS Trust Mortgage Pass-Through Certificates Series 2007-9* undead paper hanging around on your balance sheet that you agreed to service years ago?

With SEC Rule 6c-11, you can argue your case that the general public deserves to “get in on the action” (be indirectly cleaned by retail passive liquidity in legacy RMBS):

• No forced selling

• No taxable events

• Retail flows become the exit liquidity for what couldn’t be offloaded before

Why are conversions exploding now? Because institutions and funds bought everything that wasn’t nailed down after the stimulus of 2020, and now the economy is taking a turn for the worse.

Smart money isn’t buying, but retail will.

**Retail’s Belief in Passive Exposure Is Being Actively Exploited**

The genius of this arb strat is that the average investor believes they’re diversified and ignore those Fidelity/Vanguard emails like a check engine light.

The result is a passive investor class:

• Holding assets institutions used to offload risk

• Trusting liquidity that disappears in stress

• Believing they’re diversified while holding legacy exposure disguised as “themes” or “factors”

This isn’t passive. This is passive-shaped risk redistribution.

**Fed Bailout Is Growing More Difficult. It’s Not Just Political—It’s Structural.**

The 2020 SMCCF (bailout) was possible because:

• Inflation was sub-2%

• The Fed had credibility

• Fiscal stimulus had bipartisan (or at least emergency) momentum • Balance sheet expansion didn’t threaten the bond market

2025?

• Inflation is still unanchored in key areas (services, rents, wages)

• Debt/GDP is nearing structural concern levels

• QE is politically radioactive

• Bond market liquidity is thinner than it looks—we are one crisis away from **truly** dangerous levels of Treasury selling

The Fed cannot **easily** step in again. If they do, they risk:

• Unmooring inflation expectations

• Breaking bond market confidence

• Politicizing the Fed beyond repair

It’s the magic trick where retail holds the bag, Wall Street holds the applause, and the FED’s out of confetti.

Post image