Sorry for bringing this up again. Consensus seems to be VOO, citing the past ten years as proof. Doesn’t the specific timeframe matter? For example, how about the lost decade right after the dot-com bubble? These ETFs weren‘t around then, so here’s my flawed and cherry-picked example using SPY instead of VOO and the current top five aristocrat stocks from today instead of SCHD:
[https://testfol.io/?s=kqClDpIObnP](https://testfol.io/?s=kqClDpIObnP)
It’s obviously flawed but the point is that the past ten years were fantastic for the S&P and there were definitely periods where it wasn’t so hot. Doesn’t this mean that it’s possible for SCHD to out-perform VOO depending on what’s happening in the market?