Posts  / XLE  / #POST-227344
REDDIT

Oil stocks vs. crude vs. gold

W
May 14, 2026 · 21:45

It seems to me from [this chart](https://www.tradingview.com/x/sfbbYnh1/) that:

1. Oil companies (XLE, candle chart) are not a good long-term hold. Only during the first decade of this century did they do better than gold. They never do better than spot US crude itself.
2. You can make a lot more money trading crude (red line), but you can also lose a lot more.
3. Gold (purple line) is the best long-term hold.

Am I wrong?

Post image